Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bobby's avatar

Human emulators will never work because the entire premise assumes that real work is just clicking buttons in the right order, which is something only people who have never actually done operational work believe. Every demo looks amazing until the first pop-up, or the first time someone does something weird simply because they felt like it. Then the emulator faceplants.

Then there’s the verification problem. If you need a human to watch the emulator to make sure it didn’t quietly do something insane, congratulations, you’ve invented the world’s most expensive intern with a GPU bill. And if you don’t watch it, enjoy explaining to legal, compliance, or customers why your “virtual employee” confidently did the wrong thing at scale.

So sure, human emulators will look incredible in demos, internal tests, and podcasts. They’ll automate the easy 20 percent and fail catastrophically on the hard 80 percent. Which is exactly what every generation of automation has done, right before someone declares that this time it’s different.

No posts

Ready for more?